- Home
- Skills
- Business & Operations
- Validate Idea
More screenshots
Works with the AI Agents you already use
Validate Idea
This skill forces you through a rigorous, multi-phase validation framework to determine if a business or product idea has actual market legs before you write a single line of code.
Free
Validate Idea
Example session with this skill installed
/validate-idea A travel app that builds a personalized acclimatization plan for trekkers and skiers heading to high altitude. You enter your home city, destination and travel month plus a health profile, and it tells you how to prepare. Health data stays encrypted on-device; the server only ever sees city IDs + month.
- Read your context and instructions
- Compiled the validate idea
Idea validation: travel-health-acclimatization
Summary: After one refinement round, the idea cleared Phase 1 (7/10). Research then found a near-direct competitor already shipping the core feature.
Verdict: pivot, don't build as-is. All three reports are saved to ./idea-validation/travel-health-acclimatization/.
Phase 1 — Problem & idea exploration
Category: Consumer app / browser extension
Synthesis (refined to the altitude wedge)
Problem: Trekkers, skiers and climbers heading to high-elevation destinations risk acute mountain sickness (AMS) because they lack a trip-specific acclimatization plan that factors in origin vs. destination elevation, timing and personal health profile.
Audience: Adventure/altitude travelers. A specific, findable group that already researches routes, gear and permits.
Differentiator: Personalized plan (not generic "ascend slowly" advice) + privacy-first architecture (health data never leaves the device).
| Round | You | Claude | Average | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Original (all travel-health deltas) | 5 | 5 | 5 | Below 7 → you chose to refine |
| Refined (altitude wedge) | 7 | 7 | 7 | Proceed to Phase 2 |
Claude's reasoning: problem clarity and audience specificity are strong; held back from 8 because the evidence of pain is a personal allergy anecdote that doesn't map directly to the altitude wedge.
Phase 2 — Market research
Platforms (confirmed by you): Reddit, Product Hunt, Twitter/X. Hacker News and Chrome Web Store were excluded as a poor fit for a mobile consumer app.
Competitors
| Product | What it does | Threat |
|---|---|---|
| AltitudeReady | Personalized acclimation plans from home altitude, destination, fitness and activity | Near-direct |
| ARMS (US Army) | Predicts AMS risk for mission planning | Low (military, not consumer) |
| Gaia GPS | GPS/mapping with elevation risk prediction | Adjacent |
| My Altitude | Real-time altitude monitoring + SOS | Low (reactive, not pre-trip) |
Demand signals: Outfitter guides call altitude sickness "the biggest concern for most trekkers"; CDC, Healthline and outfitters publish ongoing prep guidance. No quotable first-hand forum complaints were surfaced in this pass.
Outreach candidates: None with publicly listed contact info, so no messages were drafted.
Phase 3 — Verdict
| Lens | Rating | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Evidence strength | Weak–moderate | Real competitor + published guidance confirm the problem, but not unmet demand |
| Competitive saturation | Moderate, concentrated | Few players, but AltitudeReady already owns the core feature |
| Differentiation | Weak for this wedge | Privacy-first matters most for sensitive chronic-condition data, not elevation/fitness inputs |
| Audience reachability | Good | r/Mountaineering, r/trekking, r/CampingandHiking, outfitter channels |
Recommendation: ❌ Not worth pursuing as-is
Building an altitude planner today means competing head-on with AltitudeReady on its own core feature, without your strongest differentiator being relevant. Narrowing to altitude fixed the audience problem but removed the reason for the privacy architecture.
Pivot options
Chronic-condition wedge: travelers with asthma/allergies heading to high-pollen or high-AQI destinations. No competitor found, and it's where on-device privacy actually matters.
2.
"AltitudeReady + your conditions": asthma sufferers doing high-altitude treks, where single-factor tools fall short.
3. Get first-party signal in one of the communities found above before committing.
Draft validation post (for r/trekking, for you to post yourself)
Anyone else deal with allergies/asthma AND altitude on the same trip?
I've had asthma/allergy flare-ups on trips from pollen or air quality at the destination. How do you plan around this, especially when there's altitude too? Any tools, or do you just wing it?
Next steps
- Post the validation draft and collect replies for a week
- Re-run
/validate-ideawith the chronic-condition + altitude wedge - Only once an idea gets a "go" verdict, move to planning and building
Connects securely to your tools. The creator never sees your data.
About this skill
Stop building products nobody wants. This skill forces you through a rigorous, multi-phase validation framework to determine if a business or product idea has actual market legs before you write a single line of code. It replaces gut feeling with structured research, scoring, and competitive analysis.
What it does
- Problem validation via structured interrogation to define the core problem, target audience, and unique differentiators.
- Automated market research by scouring specific platforms like Reddit, B2B SaaS directories, or local business hubs based on your idea category.
- Competitor discovery to identify 2-4 existing players and analyze their current market position and weaknesses.
- Demand signal capture by extracting specific user quotes, pain points, and links from community threads and reviews.
- Outreach drafting to create non-spammy messages for potential early adopters you identify during research.
- Final verdict reporting including a MoSCoW feature set and user stories for viable ideas, or specific pivot recommendations for weak ones.
How it works
- Exploration: You describe the idea and answer targeted questions to generate a problem synthesis and initial viability score.
- Research: The skill identifies relevant platforms and runs search patterns to find real-world evidence of the problem.
- Synthesis: It compiles demand signals and competitor lists into a structured research document in your local workspace.
- Verdict: You receive a go/no-go recommendation backed by the collected evidence, complete with a product roadmap or pivot strategy.
Frameworks & tools
This skill uses a local file-based workflow, generating Markdown reports in a dedicated project folder. It utilizes web search tools to query platforms like Reddit, G2, or LinkedIn depending on the business category.
Why this beats prompting it yourself
Standard LLM prompts often suffer from toxic positivity, telling you every idea is great. This skill uses a strict scoring rubric and mandatory search patterns to find counter-evidence, forcing a realistic "No-Go" decision when the data doesn't support the idea.
Use cases
- Validating a new B2B SaaS tool by finding specific complaints about existing market leaders.
- Testing a consumer browser extension idea against current user behavior on niche subreddits.
- Evaluating a local business concept by researching regional demand signals and existing service gaps.
Known limitations
This skill cannot bypass login-gated content or paywalls. It drafts outreach messages but will never send them or book meetings on your behalf.
- Average run: 15–30 minutes, most of it the Phase 1 interview and Phase 2 searches
- Output: three markdown reports (phase1-exploration.md, phase2-research.md, phase3-verdict.md)
- The agent scores your idea independently of you and flags it when the two scores diverge
- The skill stops at the verdict and never starts building code on its own
- Five idea categories, each with its own platform set: Consumer app / browser extension, Local business, B2B SaaS, Content / community, Generic
How to use
- 1
Connect your agent to the Agensi MCP
Copy the prompt and paste it into Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor or any agent that supports MCP. It sets up the connection for you. Manual setup
- 2
Sign in to Agensi
Your agent shows a sign-in link. Sign in and click Allow.
- 3
Ask for what you need
Your agent loads this skill and uses it on your task. It always asks before any payment.
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be one of the first to try it. Every listed skill goes through the trust checks below.
Security scanned
Checked by our 8-point scan before listing
Fresh listing
Recently published to Agensi
Free forever
No account required to browse
Trust & safety
Security scan
Security scan passed 12 days ago
- Free with an Agensi account
Permissions
File Scopes
Only writes markdown files under ./idea-validation/<idea-slug>/ in the current working directory. Reads public web pages only: no login-gated pages, no private contact info. Never sends messages, emails or posts; all outreach is drafted for the user to send.